Today’s focus is on the Israel–Hamas war that may easily expand. Ukraine is no longer the center of attention but it hasn’t gone away. These two fights are plenty for a super-power, the United States, to handle. Even if it’s not directly involved in the fighting – yet.
But trouble can easily brew up elsewhere on short notice – with the Indo-Pacific being the prime candidate.
Not surprisingly, China pays attention to the whole map – looking to maximize its interests. With the Americans tied up in the Middle East and Ukraine, Beijing perhaps sees an opportunity in its immediate neighborhood. And with Taiwan in particular.
US Military Overstretched
The US military has not forgotten about the Indo-Pacific and it is on-scene. But it can only handle so many wars at one time.
In fact, it probably hasn’t been able to fight two major wars at the same time (as it is required) for a few decades now.
Ukraine was already enough of a distraction and drain on resources. Now add in an Israel–Hamas fight that might expand to include Hezbollah and Iran. This drains off finite US military resources and attention – that are already dangerously overstretched.
There’s been plenty of talk about beefing up military forces in the Asia-Pacific since 2011 when the Obama administration announced the “Asia Pivot.” But this has never quite happened – or at least not on the scale imagined or needed.
Indeed, there’s something about Europe, the Middle East, or just about anywhere that isn’t the Indo-Pacific that attracts – and distracts American policymakers and the US military.
So now that the Middle East has heated up again (on top of Ukraine) it will be much harder to bolster US forces in the Asia-Pacific. And if US forces get directly involved in the Middle East fighting, the Indo-Pacific theater will get even shorter shrift when it comes to hardware and manpower – and even brainpower.
But can’t allies such as Japan, Australia, and South Korea make up the difference? In theory, yes. In practice, not even close.
The People’s Republic of China can “do the math.”
The Political Angle
There’s also a political angle to all this. The Biden administration (or any administration) can only focus on so many problems ー and Taiwan might be a lesser priority.
For one thing, in the United States, there is more actual and latent support for Israel than there is for Taiwan. Taiwan doesn’t have as much of a political constituency. (Think votes and funding.)
And far more Americans at least know of Israel and have a sense that it is important. This is despite the emergence of a vicious anti-Jewish constituency in the United States – and in Congress.
Few Americans know much of Taiwan. It takes a lot of effort and political will for an administration to sell the idea of risking nuclear war for “Taiwan.”
Would Team Biden make the effort if it’s tied up in Ukraine and the Middle East? That’s anybody’s guess.
China Watches
China is presumably sizing up the US response to the Israel–Hamas war in order to gauge a likely American response to an assault or serious pressure on Taiwan.
The jury is still out, though. For now, the Biden administration is mostly backing Israel. However, there are indications it wants Israel to pull its punches. And now that Israeli forces have gone into Gaza, wait a couple of weeks. We’ll see if Team Biden tells the Israelis that they’ve “defended themselves enough” and it’s time for a ceasefire or so-called humanitarian pauses to let Hamas catch its breath.
If so, Xi Jinping will take note.
Unfortunately, Xi will also note the Biden administration’s initial reaction to the Hamas massacres on October 7. It was ambiguous and seemed to consider Hamas and Israel as equally at fault.
Applied to a Taiwan scenario one imagines the State Department issuing a tweet hours after the People’s Liberation Army hammers Taiwan:
“Taiwan, don’t respond. Violence solves nothing.”
If Beijing reckons an attack on Taiwan will result in some tut-tutting and faux outrage and then a move to double down on diplomacy, well, that’ll be fine. And if it has to wait a couple of weeks as Washington makes a show of trying to aid Taiwan before letting it go, that will be fine too.
Read more.
