Moderate Muslim voices deserve to be heard in America

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Originally published by Arab News

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

US far-left Rep. Ilhan Omar and two of her colleagues have reintroduced the Combating International Islamophobia Act, which they claim will tackle the global rise in Islamophobia. The bill mandates the creation of a special envoy for monitoring and combating Islamophobia within the State Department, along with a comprehensive strategy to establish US leadership in fighting Islamophobia worldwide. However, the bill’s narrow focus on Islamophobia raises concerns about biased priorities. Singling out one religious group potentially undermines the principles of equality and fairness that lawmakers should uphold.

The bill aims to establish US dominance on this issue, raising questions about the appropriateness and effectiveness of such an approach. Collaboration and cooperation with other nations would be more conducive to fostering understanding and promoting tolerance on an international scale.

Omar, with her usual zeal, implored US lawmakers to expedite the passage of this bill, emphasizing that “anti-Muslim bigotry is a global phenomenon.” By framing the issue as interconnected and genuinely global, she attempts to rally support for her cause. Her partnership with Sen. Cory Booker and Rep. Jan Schakowsky is touted as a means to establish a special envoy tasked with eradicating this alleged bigotry.

Despite the bill’s previous failure to pass the Senate in 2021, Omar remains determined to build momentum and secure its enactment into law. However, her statements should be critically examined. While it is essential to acknowledge and address instances of discrimination, her portrayal of anti-Muslim bigotry as a sweeping global problem oversimplifies a complex issue. By presenting it as a monolithic phenomenon, she risks disregarding the unique regional and cultural contexts in which such incidents occur.

But why is an American Muslim like myself standing against this bill, along with many other similar-minded Muslims who know firsthand what political Islamism is all about?

Upon initial examination, the creation of this special envoy position may appear commendable, as the leader of the free world acknowledges the victims’ plight and stands ready to defend them if necessary. That being said, the reality reveals quite the opposite upon closer scrutiny. The term “Islamophobia” itself raises skepticism, particularly as it emerges as nothing more than a fabrication of political Islamists who seek to silence the dissenting Muslim voices that question their motives and oppose their totalitarian ideology in the name of religious freedom. Astonishingly, the bill passed the US House of Representatives in 2021, despite failing to provide a precise and accurate definition of what constitutes Islamophobia.

The very concept of Islamophobia, as proposed by political Islamists, presents a troubling scenario. It weaponizes the term to stifle any criticism or questioning of their actions, eroding the fundamental principles of freedom of speech and intellectual discourse. This not only silences the Muslim voices that dare to challenge the political Islamist agenda, but it also hinders the ability to have an open and honest dialogue about the complex issues surrounding Islam in the West.

Read more.

Ilhan Omar by Lorie Shaull is licensed under CC BY 2.0

Please Share: